Mauricio Pochettino is leaving the U.S. men’s national team for Manchester United, despite signing an extension through 2030 only three months ago. United will reportedly pay the $10 million buyout required to dislodge him from his position, but where will U.S. Soccer go with their war-chest from here?

Whoever gets the job will inherit a program that feels on the up, though that is not an unfamiliar feeling for USMNT fans. In the September and October international windows, Pochettino called up a swathe of burgeoning domestic stars, most of whom are still teenagers. 

That young group put on a handful of sparkling displays, winning four out of four games by a combined score of 12-3, giving fans a glimpse into a potentially exciting cycle headed towards the 2030 World Cup.

The task on hand for U.S. Soccer is massive, however. The next coach will not only be tasked with leading this promising set of players into the 2027 Gold Cup, 2028 Copa America, and 2030 World Cup on the pitch, but off the pitch, they will have to keep up with the massive cultural strides Pochettino made in his two years as boss. 

While his time as head coach was not trophy-laden by any means, the Argentine brought a more worldly, serious feel to the national team that some, albeit more successful, domestic managers have been unable to capture in the past. 

The dilemma is simple now for U.S. Soccer — do they stick with globally recognizable managers with the risk of them not taking to the domestic soccer culture quite as much as Pochettino? Or do they revert back to type and go for a coach with more understanding of the many quirks that come with American soccer.

There is the potential for any sort of domestic coach to feel like an underwhelming presence after two years of Pochettino. Will the players feel as compelled to give total buy-in to a coach that has only found success in MLS? On the flip side, joining the queue for the ‘big name’ international coach merry-go-round could prove to quell what makes the USMNT stand out from the rest of the pack. 

With those factors to take in, let’s take a look at a few different candidates that could fill Pochettino’s shoes in the coming months. 

Pochettino is leaving the USMNT with an unexpected vacancy just three months after signing a new deal. (Mark Thorstenson/ISI Photos via Getty Images)

Roberto Martinez

Martinez has been linked to the job in recent days after finding himself out of work for the last few months. The former Premier League boss resigned from the Portugal job this past summer in the wake of their elimination from the 2026 World Cup in the round-of-16.

Should U.S. Soccer want to enter into the aforementioned ‘big name’ international coach conversation, Martinez would be a natural option given his lengthy CV. Yet, many may feel underwhelmed by the hire. The Spaniard has shown little ability to elevate the ceilings of his respective squads.

As Belgium coach, Martinez lead the side to almost comical tournament exits despite the Red Devils consistently finding themselves the top-three of FIFA Rankings. With Portugal, it was much of the same though the job was made harder by the ungraceful aging of Cristiano Ronaldo.

BJ Callaghan

If the federation wants an American, Callaghan is the very first name the decision makers should be looking towards. He spent five years as a USMNT assistant under Gregg Berhalter, has already served as interim coach, and just lead Nashville SC to arguably the best MLS regular season in league history. He’s widely seen as one of the best young American coaches around.

The obvious concern is inexperience, however. He’s only a couple of years into his first senior head-coaching job, which would make him the least experienced coach the program has hired in the modern era. Reports suggest U.S. Soccer has been leaning toward more seasoned candidates, so his time might come a little later. But if continuity and a homegrown coach are the priorities, he makes a lot of sense.

Steve Cherundolo

Cherundolo remains an outside shout, but given the federation already trusts him enough to hand him the interim job, he must in the conversation. Cherundolo is a former USMNT player — a well respected one at that — and former LAFC head coach, with coaching experience in Germany and a stint on the national team staff back in 2018. He knows the players, the culture and the people at the top.

The question is ambition from the point of view of the federation. After landing a name as big as Pochettino, will U.S. Soccer settle for a former MLS coach who was largely criticized for his conservative style of play and inability to truly dominate with one of the most expensive squads in the league? A strong showing in the interim games would help him a lot, but it may not be enough.

Wilfried Nancy

Nancy is certainly the wild card of the group. Plenty of people consider him one of the best managers in MLS history having built a dominant Columbus Crew team between 2022-2025. The Frenchman is currently unemployed though reports have frequently suggest that he remains keen on working his way up the ladder in European club football.

What’s more, Nancy’s propensity to play a style of soccer built upon crucial tactical principles could prove to be an obstacle given the lack of time on the training ground for international sides. But if long-term growth as a unit is the aim, it may be just fine with some required patience.

Pep Guardiola

Finally, the true top target for U.S. Soccer. If Pep Guardiola is available, you make the call, regardless of if you think anybody is going to answer the phone. Guardiola has shown a great affinity for American life in recent years, living in New York City while on a sabbatical after leaving Bayern Munich.

“The USA is fascinating to try to build a project for many years and being able to get the national team to the next step,” the Catalan said in the past. “The potential with the USA is there for the amount of people and sports and so on.”

Reports have already suggest that he may not be keen on ending his current sabbatical quite yet, but perhaps he can be pitched a project he simply can not say no to. Guardiola, like Pochettino before him, has no experience coaching at the international level, but like Pochettino before him, his ability to make seismic cultural changes can not be ignored.

If Guardiola shows an interest, it is a no-brainer.

Adam is a soccer writer based in Portland, Oregon